Ability-to-Pay: Horizontal equity

 The theory of ability-to-pay is closely related to the principle of horizontal equity in taxation. Horizontal equity refers to the idea that individuals with similar abilities to pay should pay similar amounts of taxes, regardless of their income levels. In other words, it ensures that people with the same economic capacity should pay the same taxes, regardless of their income level.

The principle of horizontal equity is based on the idea that taxation should be fair and equal for all citizens. If two individuals have the same economic capacity, they should bear the same tax burden, regardless of their income levels. This ensures that no one is unfairly burdened or advantaged by the tax system.

A flat tax system is often seen as an example of horizontal equity, as it applies the same tax rate to all citizens regardless of their income levels. The flat tax system is easy to administer and it is simple to understand. Furthermore, it creates a sense of fairness as everyone pays the same percentage of their income in taxes.

However, horizontal equity can also be incorporated into progressive taxation systems. In a progressive tax system, people with similar abilities to pay but with different income levels would be in the same tax bracket and pay the same percentage of their income in taxes. This ensures that people with the same ability to pay would be paying the same amount of taxes, but would still result in a progressive overall tax system where people with higher incomes would pay more in absolute terms.

Horizontal equity can also be considered when designing tax exemptions, credits, and deductions. For example, the Earned Income Tax Credit is a credit that is aimed at helping low-income workers by providing them with credit on their taxes. However, if the credit is only available to a certain group of individuals, it would not be considered as horizontally equitable. It would be considered fair and equitable only if it is available to all citizens regardless of their income levels.

Additionally, horizontal equity in taxation also includes the principle of neutrality, which implies that the tax system should not discriminate between different types of economic activities or industries. For example, a tax system that imposes higher taxes on small businesses as compared to large corporations would not be considered as horizontally equitable as it would put small businesses at a disadvantage.

You may also like:

• What is GINI coefficient?
• Sources of public revenue in India

In conclusion, horizontal equity is an important principle in the theory of ability-to-pay. It ensures that individuals with similar abilities pay to bear the same tax burden regardless of their income levels. This principle can be incorporated into both flat and progressive tax systems, and it is important to ensure that tax exemptions, credits, and deductions are also designed to be horizontally equitable. However, designing a tax system that satisfies both horizontal and vertical equity can be challenging as achieving one often comes at the expense of the other.